I consider myself a fairly capable fantasy football player and I’ll put my history up against that of nearly anyone else. But a couple seasons ago I was stumped. I entered the championship game on a roll, having won seven of nine matchups including my semifinal game a week earlier.
But during that game my running backs were decimated with injuries and I was left with little more than waiver-wire options to stock my lineup with for Championship Sunday.
I had a couple ideas but thought I could use some additional guidance - so for the first time ever I emailed the guys at Fantasy Football Weekly, billed as the longest-running show on KFAN-AM radio in the Twin Cities (the show starts up again this Saturday, Aug. 2, at 10 a.m. central time and is podcast-able shortly afterward by clicking “Fan on Demand” at www.KFAN.com).
Paul Charchian, co-host of Fantasy Football Weekly and now founder of LeagueSafe®, and his colleagues recommended I pick up and start both Ron Dayne and Michael Pittman, one at running back and the other in a flex-position. They scored 18 and 9 points respectively helping me to a 64-63 win that netted a nice championship check and bragging rights over a group of east coasters wondering why a country bumpkin from the midwest was even in their league.
A few weeks ago Charchian noticed a post on this site and when contacted by Zoneblitz he graciously agreed to answer some questions and share his thoughts on what to expect during the season ahead.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Zoneblitz: Peterson or Tomlinson (or someone else) with the top pick in the draft and why?
Paul Charchian: There is no player in the NFL that I’d rather watch than Adrian Peterson. But, it’s Tomlinson, and it’s not close. Tomlinson’s consistency is unparalleled at the position. I’m a big fan of drafting guys I can count upon, week in and week out. Tomlinson’s hasn’t had a bad season since…uh…never. He’s never had less than 10 touchdowns, and he’s averaging 2070 yards from scrimmage since his rookie year. Unreal!
Zoneblitz: What players at QB, RB, WR/TE do you see as potential under-the-radar guys who could really bust out with big fantasy seasons?
Charchian: (Average Draft Position data courtesy of MockDraftCentral.)
QB – Jake Delhomme. ADP QB ranking: 17. Charch’s ranking: 11.
When healthy, he’s a great quarterback, and his rehab from elbow surgery is going fine. A quick refresher of last year’s pre-injury stats: in 2.75 games, he racked up eight touchdown passes with just one interception. He’s got a plethora of receiving options, including three new options in Mushin Muhammad, DJ Hackett, and Jonathan Stewart who is getting tons of receptions in training camp.
RB – Jonathan Stewart. ADP RB ranking: 29. Charch’s ranking: 18.
Yes, another Panther. People are actually shying away from Stewart because of DeAngelo Williams? Really? While a dynamic runner, Williams hasn’t shown anything to suggest that he’ll be a fantasy factor. Stewart will run behind an improved line, he’s clearly the goal line guy, and John Fox loves to pound the ball whenever possible.
WR – Jabar Gaffney. ADP WR ranking: 52. Charch’s ranking: 29.
Gaffney made a strong move at the tail end of last season, displacing a lot of Donte Stallworth’s playing time, and eventually making Stallworth expendable in the offseason. Gaffney scored in four of the Patriots’ final six regular season games, and added another touchdown in the playoffs. He certainly was trending toward fantasy viability at the end of last year. Those solid numbers came despite the presence of Wes Welker and Randy Moss. Think of what could happen if the increasingly brittle Moss were to go down.
TE – Donald Lee. ADP TE ranking: 17. Charch’s ranking: 8.
Lee turned a corner in the second half of last season, catching five touchdowns in the final seven games. His improvements led to Bubba Franks being cut in the offseason, which opens the door for Lee’s full time use this year. Even with Franks on the roster last year, Lee caught a pass in every game, and caught multiple passes in 13 games. Inexperienced quarterbacks, like Aaron Rogers, tend to dump off to their safety valve tight end.
Zoneblitz: Who do you see at those same positions being potential busts this season?
Charchian:
QB – Matt Hasselbeck. ADP QB ranking: 8. Charch’s ranking: 17.
Hasselbeck is a good quarterback, but there is such an alarming dearth of surrounding talent that I can’t envision him delivering consistent fantasy points. First, there’s no running game to keep defenses honest. No, Julius Jones doesn’t help in any real way. Opponents will key on Hasselbeck in every game. His offensive line was lousy last year, and the addition of Mike Wahle doesn’t improve it—just ask Jake Delhomme/Matt Moore/Vinny Testaverde/David Carr. Lastly, his receivers get hurt a lot, and none of them are a true No. 1.
RB - Earnest Graham. ADP RB ranking: 18th RB. Charch’s ranking: 34.
Concerns abound. Jon Gruden has repeatedly described the Bucs running back situation as RBBC. Warrick Dunn and Michael Bennett will play a role, and Caddy lurks as a second-half vulture. Gruden has a long history of RBBC, going back to his Oakland days. Remember Zack Crockett stealing goal line carries? In general, Tampa’s offense is already shaky, but what happens if Garcia goes down? Can Brian Griese really power an already aged, wobbly offense? Luke McCown? Chris Simms? Lastly, Graham’s new contract was very team friendly. Anyone who thinks the Bucs will use him because they paid him isn’t familiar with his deal.
WR – Jerricho Cotchery (before the Favre trade). ADP WR ranking: 31. Charch’s ranking: 51.
What am I missing here? He’s the No. 2 receiver on a team with horrible quarterbacking. How does he crack the top 32? Doesn’t every NFL team have someone better than Cotchery? As a starter for the better part of three years, he’s averaged 2.6 touchdowns per year. Sure, he’s caught 82 passes the last two years, which gives him a smidgeon of PPR value, but enough to be ranked 31? He failed to top 60 yards eight times last year. I don’t see enough improvement on the Jets roster to account for the public’s fascination with him.
TE - Vernon Davis. ADP TE ranking: 8. Charch’s ranking: 15.
Let’s start by looking at his resume to date. Injuries? Check. Invisible stat lines? Check. Inconsistent performances? Check. Gee, sounds great so far! But, that’s the past. Let’s look ahead. Davis has gained an offensive coordinator who doesn’t know that the tight end position is on the field. In a recent interview, Mike Martz acknowledged that his offenses don’t highlight tight ends, and that he doesn’t expect that to change (although Martz says that he hopes Davis’ YPC will improve). And, then there’s the team’s dreadful quarterback position. Shawn Hill and Alex Smith should be battling to see who gets to do my taxes; not who gets to lead an NFL offense.
Part 2 of the interview upcoming (including a discussion on leaguesafe.com).